It’s Time to Cancel Cancel Culture: Why Understanding Matters More Than Condemnation
Over the past several years, a troubling shift in social discourse has emerged—one that thrives on outrage, punishment, and the public shaming of individuals for perceived wrongs. What began as a tool to hold people accountable has metastasized into a culture of fear, where one misstep, one ill-phrased comment, or one past mistake can lead to social exile. Cancel culture, as it has come to be known, has outlived its usefulness. It is time to move beyond condemnation and embrace understanding.
The Problem with Cancel Culture
At its core, cancel culture is about exclusion. It operates under the assumption that people are irredeemable, that past mistakes define an individual’s worth indefinitely, and that public shaming is an appropriate response to disagreement or transgression. While accountability is necessary in any just society, cancel culture too often substitutes mob judgment for meaningful conversation.
In its current form, cancel culture breeds fear rather than progress. People self-censor rather than risk speaking candidly, making genuine dialogue all but impossible. Worse, it fosters a culture of performative outrage, where individuals seek to “win” moral superiority rather than engage in good-faith discussion. This dynamic assumes that those doing the canceling always possess the correct perspective, but history shows us that prevailing opinions can often be flawed. True progress comes not from rigid dogma but from an openness to differing perspectives and ongoing debate.
Understanding Over Condemnation
The alternative to cancel culture is not blind forgiveness or a lack of consequences; it is a return to empathy, context, and the ability to learn and grow. Understanding does not mean excusing harmful behavior, but it does mean recognizing that people are complex, capable of change, and often acting within contexts we may not fully grasp.
We must replace knee-jerk reactions with curiosity. Instead of instantly condemning someone for a mistake, we should ask: What was their intent? What shaped their beliefs? Are they open to learning? Can I learn from them? True accountability is not about destruction—it is about growth. If we want people to change, we must allow them the opportunity to do so and we must be open to change ourselves.
How We Move Forward
Encourage Nuanced Conversations – Complex issues require discussion, not absolutism. We must be willing to listen, ask questions, and consider perspectives different from our own.
Recognize the Humanity in Others – No one is perfect. We should judge others not just by their past, but by their willingness to learn and improve. Redemption should be possible.
Promote Constructive Accountability – There is a difference between accountability and cancellation. The former involves understanding, growth, and proportional consequences. The latter is punitive and final. We must differentiate between the two.
Reject the Social Media Mob Mentality – Online outrage spreads like wildfire, often based on incomplete information. Instead of contributing to knee-jerk outrage, we should take a step back, seek context, and resist the urge to destroy rather than discuss.
Model Forgiveness – If we want to live in a society where people are free to grow, we must practice forgiveness ourselves. That does not mean excusing wrongdoing but allowing room for people to make amends.
A Culture That Heals, Not Harms
Cancel culture, in its current form, is unsustainable. It stifles dialogue, erodes trust, and leaves little room for growth. If we want a better society—one that values accountability without cruelty—we must shift from condemnation to understanding.
We need a culture that fosters curiosity over outrage, conversation over condemnation, and grace over destruction. Instead of seeking to punish, we should seek to understand. Instead of silencing, we should seek to engage. Only then can we build a society where people are not defined by their worst moments, but by our shared ability to work through them.
It’s time to cancel cancel culture—and replace it with something better.
Signup to receive a weekly roundup of new posts